[Gameplay] Logistics

[badmojo420]

Originally Posted by RCMoonPie

So....what if I am on Kashan, US side, in a tank helping helping to take the south bunker....and I need repairs? A supply truck drops off a single crate at my location.(if I am lucky to get this new 2 seater that will most likely be one-manned) I am waiting on repairs to slowly happen....and then my box disappears. By the above post's logic.....I am expected to limp back to base to get full repairs.....removong me and my vehicle from the battle....instead of helping with a potential push forward to other flags?

Read this WHOLE thread before getting all worked up over a couple posts. It was already stated that a repair crate will repair you fully. Unless that supply truck drops another one before your done repairing. Or after 5mins it'll disappear. But no repair takes 5mins. Also, who really cares if a supply truck is 1 manned? Isn't that more logical? Risk only 1 life instead of 2. All you need is a driver.

Originally Posted by RCMoonPie

And now.....with the rally-point reformatting.....If I am attacking that same south bunker as infantry.....and I was carrying a Auto Kit, a grenadier kit, or a LAT kit.....and if I am killed.....my squad will have to do without.....at least for a long time.
I will have to either spawn at the main to get it back......and pray I have a ride from a pubby who is one-manning the new 2 seater truck or some other form of APC that is most likely relocated to a single squad that isnt mine.....or spawn at my rally and beg my pubby SL to request a resupply from the same one-manned truck......or hope that some other pubby had the forethought to place a box or a repair point somewhere close by......and try to get to it before it disappears to magically re-appear somewhere else for the next squad down the line at a new flag.

First of all, how did you get to south bunker? Transport choppers (littlebird excluded) drop supply crates. I can see it becoming common practice to drop a crate when inserting troops. Same with an APC. If he brought you in, he should stick around to ensure your squad has kits. And PLEASE for the love of god, don't ask the new logistics trucks to pick you up and transport you somewhere. Unless you're going where they're going, stay out. And the supply crates don't magically disappear, and you can't request kits off the repair crates or depot as far as i've read. So i don't know what you're going on about there.

[space]

Originally Posted by RCMoonPie

There is a saying common here in the states...."If it isn't broke...don't fix it."

And saying as its a realism mod, dont the military also say K.I.S.S (Keep It Simple Stupid)

Id rather 0.85 came out 2 months later, than be released with problems, that were stuck with for 6 months. I hope its play tested and I'm sure it will be, but in 0.8 the deviation problems and over adjusted sprint/grenades were apparent to me within an hour or two of playing 0.8, and those problems got though. Those 3 minor problems, have made some maps almost unplayable for me personally.

My main concern is the fact that we will have more people walking long distances and more people travelling backwards and forwards, acting as delivery men. It will decrease fighting at the front, and slow down the game even more.

Logistics squads would be great if BF2 was 128 players, but its not - and it seems like the changes will use up alot of the (maximum) 32 players, travelling around instead of fighting.

Im aware that all this sounds very negative - the vast majority of the changes sound great, and even the other changes are in the right direction, but it does sound to me like they need tweaking a little.

[space]

Originally Posted by badmojo420

Also, who really cares if a supply truck is 1 manned? Isn't that more logical? Risk only 1 life instead of 2. All you need is a driver.
And PLEASE for the love of god, don't ask the new logistics trucks to pick you up and transport you somewhere. Unless you're going where they're going, stay out.

The problem there is that anyone can drive the truck, with any kit, so if a guy is stuck at main, he'll use it as a taxi, and abandon it at the front.

[[R-DEV]OkitaMakoto]

Maybe something to look into is to give the logistics truck a relatively short decay timer so when it is empty for say, 3 minutes away from the main base[base is spawns at] is will explode and a new one will spawn in quickly.

This would mean a team using it will almost always have it occupied, and thus would not ave to worry about the short decay timer of it, but on the other hand, if a tard takes it as a taxi, all is not lost because it will shortly explode and respawn at the main...

Though, people would really need to be aware of the decay timer, as even a good logistics squad would on occasion need to leave it unoccupied for short periods of time

Always something to look into anyway...

[badmojo420]

That's miss-using the vehicle. Saying someone is 1 manning implies that more people are required to operate effectively. And how is that any different then people grabbing jeeps or engineers taking cmd trucks and using them as taxis now? And since they are removing engineer, it would be stupid to limit the truck to just one kit. Which kit would it be? Crewman and the driver is useless outside the truck? Medic and everyone who doesn't like medic is foreced into the role if they want to do logistics? Officer, no that wouldn't work. The only thing left is rifleman, might as well make it any kit. See what i'm getting at?

[badmojo420]

Originally Posted by [R-DEV]OkitaMakoto

Maybe something to look into is to give the logistics truck a relatively short decay timer so when it is empty for say, 3 minutes away from the main base[base is spawns at] is will explode and a new one will spawn in quickly.

This would mean a team using it will almost always have it occupied, and thus would not ave to worry about the short decay timer of it, but on the other hand, if a tard takes it as a taxi, all is not lost because it will shortly explode and respawn at the main...

Though, people would really need to be aware of the decay timer, as even a good logistics squad would on occasion need to leave it unoccupied for short periods of time

Always something to look into anyway...

That might actually increase people using it as taxi. I can hear it now...

"Sq3 why did you abandon that supply truck?"
"Oh don't worry, it'll respawn back there in 3 mins"

Call me evil but i believe a team should be effected by the incompetence of its' players. Otherwise people won't bother explaining to the idiots why what they're doing is wrong. And then they'll never learn. Also it would be great to secure the enemy supply trucks and keep the enemy from getting any supplies to the front.

[[R-DEV]Deer]

Game is just more fun when problems has got solutions which works for casual players as well. If solution doesnt work for casual players, we are facing frustrating situations while playing and nobody likes it..

[arjan]

I wanna do ambushes on supply lines in 0.85!

[sakils2]

I wanna do ambushes on supply lines in 0.85

Me too
Works in 0.8, though :P

[[R-DEV]OkitaMakoto]

It sort of just dawned on me how much this is really going to bring tanks and APCs down to a more realistic level.

Just watched a .8 video of a tank taking some hits, destroying the target, then simply saying "Hey, engy, wanna hop out and repair us?"

No longer is that gonna happen and I cant wait

In .85 if you get a solid hit on a tank you KNOW its going to matter, even if you dont take it out. Same with APCs



DDaaaaaaaaaaamn

I take any small annoyances that come from smacktards in exchange for this change